Taste Buds magazine logo
Arundell Arms dining room table

Arundell Arms

Katy Hanley samples some fine dining at this two AA-rosette restaurant

Is the Arundell Arms a pub or a hotel with fine dining? It seems to do both equally well and the restaurant has held two AA rosettes continuously since 1987.

The hotel is a fishing establishment. It has fishing rights to seven local rivers and organises fishing lessons if needed, or advice and maps if not. It is also definitely a hotel – you have to walk through the main reception area to get to either the bar or the restaurant.

The dining room was traditional and formal: there were large heavy curtains, tablecloths, an illuminated chandelier and classical music playing. We could have a ‘tasting menu’ or the à la carte (which we chose). The bar area was busier than the restaurant and you could see why: the prices for this standard of food are very good for a pub – it uses the same kitchen as the restaurant and is less formal, which some people prefer. I noticed that the bar area was fully occupied.

The amuses-bouches were appreciated; my companion particularly liked her broccoli tempura. I liked the fact that as one of us was vegetarian and the other wasn’t, we got separate mini plates of these appetisers.

My companion said that there was a good choice of vegetarian dishes on the menu. She had the Vulscombe goats’ cheese with salad as a starter. This looked beautiful; the salad was delicate and prettily arranged, with the salad vegetables complementing the creamy goats’ cheese. She chose the pastry croustade of Provençal vegetables for main course – this was served with a creamy sauce that was pronounced delicious. This was followed by the lemon crème brûlée, which was served with a poppy seed shortbread. The brûlée was fragrant and there was a delicate crunch from the biscuit.

I am less of a vegetarian and chose the John Dory to start. This was delicate and well cooked. I particularly liked the crispy piece of kale perched on the top. The duck I had for main course was served pink and I was pleased to find it sitting on top of a potato galette – this went superbly with the duck and there was plenty of rich jus to go with it. Someone in the kitchen is a whizz at making sauces as they were all noticeably delicious.

For dessert I had the candied ginger parfait with sugared doughnut and poached rhubarb. The parfait was a large scoop of creamy yet tangy dessert, served at exactly the right temperature (icy cold but not too solid) and accompanied by a small beignet filled with tiny pieces of perfectly pink rhubarb. The rhubarb stems were seasonally slender, and there was a striking contrast between the rich beignet and the tender morsels of rhubarb nestling at its centre. Many of the dishes were on the smaller side of things – but they were done well and tasted good.

The bar area had quietened down as we left. This place is both a comfortable pub with very good food and a more refined hotel with restaurant – the choice is up to the lucky customer.

Sample Menu

  • Char-grilled ‘Lifton’ asparagus
  • Pan-fried Brixham scallops
  • Roasted best-end of English lamb with herb crust
  • Pan-fried cutlet of turbot, with a fricassee of Brixham scallops
  • Lemon crème brûlée Ginger parfait with doughnut


  • Starters from £9.50
  • Mains from £19.50
  • Desserts £8.95

“Someone in the kitchen is a whizz at making sauces as they were all noticeably delicious.”
Arundell Arms
1 Fore Street
Devon PL16 0AA

01566 784666

About Taste Buds magazine

Taste Buds is published by We Make Magazines, a family-owned Devon company. Taste Buds is produced using Devon-based writers, chefs, photographers and sales team. It is printed on environmentally friendly paper.

… just like the food we write about, Taste Buds is lovingly made using the finest local ingredients!

Tell us what you think…

Taste Buds is your magazine. If you know of a business that you would like to share with other readers we would love to hear from you.

Publishing Enquiries
Jeff Cooper: 01626 871161

Editorial Enquiries
Jennie Cooper: 01626 871161

Advertising Enquiries
Julie Hutchins: 07843 621463

Prefer Print?

The MayJune 2020 issue of Taste Buds is out now