Boringdon Hall Hotel

Katy Hanley experiences a culinary adventure at this historic hotel near Plymouth

Restaurant Review

Approached along a tree-lined drive, Boringdon Hall near Plymouth resembles a mini-castle with turrets, a minstrel’s gallery, moulded high ceilings and a welcoming fire. Stuffed with atmosphere, there’s a new spa, which I would like to investigate further…

The restaurant in the gallery upstairs was full, and the Grand Hall, where we sat for pre-dinner drinks, was indeed grand yet relaxing. The classical music playing was in keeping with the venue, where old oak pillars and beams were softened by luxurious, velvet-covered sofas.

The food was exquisite. The amuse bouche was served in a mini Kilner jar with three layers inside – the waiter mentioned that it was strong. It was delicious: there was a layer of pear compote and one of cheese panna cotta with chives.

I had the oh-so-tender pork belly with cassoulet as a starter. My husband had the veal sweetbreads with a Teriyaki chicken wing and mouli. Both dishes had a certain flair, so we were greatly looking forward to the rest of our meal.

I had the duck for main course. There were all manner of vegetables and surprises on my plate and I thoroughly enjoyed it. My husband chose the deer with beetroot – the meat was cooked perfectly, accompanied by a rich, dark sauce. 

For dessert I chose the sugar tart. Served with apple sorbet and figs, it was like a caramel custard tart with a crème brûlée crust. My husband couldn’t decide, so he asked the waiter to bring “something good”. He wasn’t disappointed, being served a hazelnut praline with ‘forest floor’ – a decadent combination of chocolate, nuts and berry flavours.

There was a surprise in each dish. For example, my duck was served with a crispy, edible ‘cigar’. The Head Chef, Scott Paton, is certainly living up to his growing reputation – I don't think it will be long before he becomes a household name – as the food the kitchen produced was so good.

We had the Jing tea ceremony after dessert (Moroccan Rose for me, Gunpowder for my other half). This was bit of theatre that we enjoyed immensely to end our remarkable culinary adventure. 

Katy loves: The grandeur, the duck cigar, the waiting staff, the atmosphere, the tea ceremony

Sample Menu


  • Smoked pork belly, white bean cassoulet, parliament sauce and garlic sausage
  • Braised Anjou pigeon, brioche porridge, chestnut purée and Perigord truffle
  • Vulscombe goats’ cheese terrine and pickled beetroots, elderflower and gingerbread           

Main Courses 

  • Crispy artichokes, puffed wheats and grains, celery and goats’ curds           
  • Hurdon Farm pork collar, Crown Prince pumpkin, prunes and Armagnac                
  • Pan-fried fillet of stone bass, Thai-scented purée and lemongrass dressing


  • Set custard tart, blackberry posset, green apple sorbet                           
  • Dulcey chocolate tart, salted peanut and sour cherry                              
  • Hazelnut parfait, forest floor and pear sorbet 


  • Starters from £8
  • Mains from £18
  • Desserts from £9
Boringdon Hall Hotel and Spa
01752 344455
Katy Hanley

Published 19 December 2016

You may also be interested in…

Restaurant Review

Breakwater Bistro, Brixham

Fiona Griffiths enjoys wholesome, home-cooked food at this popular eatery

Read more…

Restaurant Review

Woolacombe Bay Hotel, Woolacombe

Sue Cade enjoys all things coastal and top-notch service at this special North Devon hotel

Read more…

Restaurant Review

The Orangery Restaurant, Kenton

Jennie and Jeff Cooper relish the home-cooked dishes at this bustling, bright restaurant

Read more…

Restaurant Review

Otter Garden Centre, Plymouth

Sue Cade gives into temptation and enjoys fresh flavours at this restaurant

Read more…

Restaurant Review

Valley View Café, Loddiswell

Lucy Baker-Kind finds out why this eatery is fast becoming a South Hams favourite

Read more…

Restaurant Review

Home Farm Café

Karen Perrow savours this popular eatery's rustic charm and flavoursome food

Read more…

View the archive